Skip to content

Free guide Β· Professional Dilemmas

MSRA SJT ranking and select-three questions explained

Three things to remember.

  • Ranking compares independent actions
  • Selection considers a combination of three
  • Read the exact task before judging options
Full answer and context

The MSRA Professional Dilemmas paper has two tasks: rank actions from most to least appropriate, or select three appropriate actions. Read the instruction on each scenario before judging the options; the tasks need different responses.

Pause before revealing

Check what stuck.

What is the key difference between the two PD tasks?

Compare your answer

Ranking judges each action's appropriateness; selection judges the combination.

Self-check Β· no score saved
Ranking: compare every action

A ranking scenario presents several plausible actions. Look for the immediate issue and the role you have been given, then compare how each action addresses it. An action can be better than another without being perfect. Read the official rationale after a practice attempt and ask why neighbouring options changed places.

Selection: choose a group of three

A select-three question asks you to choose the three responses that work best together. Think about whether your choices collectively address the main problem, communication and appropriate escalation. Do not turn the task into a ranking of all the options: it is a different format. The official paper explains the exact scoring, including partial credit and no negative marking.

How to revise without learning a false rule

Professional Dilemmas are set in the context of an F2 doctor. A shortcut such as β€œalways tell a senior first” may fail when the situation calls for a proportionate, immediate or patient-centred action. For each missed question, write one sentence on the conflict or priority. Compare it with the official rationale, then try a new scenario later.

Use the free Professional Dilemmas hub for a short reasoning exercise. The official sample is the best place to see both formats together.

Scroll to Top