Skip to content

Professional Dilemmas · free revision

Think clearly.
Act thoughtfully.

Build a repeatable way to read MSRA Professional Dilemmas, then practise the ranking and select-three formats with reviewed scenarios as they become available.

Start in a few minutes

One small step today.

Professional Dilemmas is the situational judgement part of the MSRA. The question asks what an F2 doctor should do in the situation described. The details matter more than a memorised slogan.

The paper has 50 scenarios. Around half ask for a ranking; the others ask you to choose three actions. There is no negative marking. Check the current NHS England paper guide ↗

The blueprint

Three lenses for the same dilemma.

NHS England names three professional competencies. A scenario can ask you to balance more than one.

Professional integrity

Look for honesty, appropriate boundaries, responsibility and fair treatment. Ask who is affected if an action avoids the issue.

Coping with pressure

Notice workload, uncertainty and limits of competence. Seeking appropriate help can be part of a sound response.

Empathy and sensitivity

Consider the patient or colleague's perspective, dignity and communication as well as the immediate practical problem.

These are learning prompts based on the NHS England PD competencies and GMC Good medical practice. They are not an answer key.

Know what the task asks

Two formats. Two ways to think.

RANK FOUR OR FIVE

Judge each action on its own.

Put the independent actions from most to least appropriate. They are not steps in a timeline. Compare close neighbours by asking which deals more directly and fairly with the concern.

Quick format check

If one action could happen before another, does that alone make it rank higher? No. NHS England asks you to judge each action's appropriateness independently.

SELECT THREE

Build a complete response.

Choose three actions from at least eight options. Consider how the three work together to address the situation; avoid a set that leaves a significant concern unresolved.

Quick format check

Is choosing three individually pleasant-sounding actions enough? Check whether the combination resolves the actual problem in the scenario.

The official guide explains the formats and scoring. Ranking can receive credit for an order close to the predetermined key; the site does not turn a short practice score into an exam prediction.

A useful habit

The ten-minute review loop.

Use it with one reviewed question. Take longer when the explanation reveals a gap.

  1. Read the role.What can this F2 doctor know, decide and do in the situation given?
  2. Find the immediate concern.Notice patient safety, honesty, workload, communication and who needs help.
  3. Commit to the format.Rank independent actions, or select a set of three that works together.
  4. Explain the closest call.Before revealing, say why one plausible action is stronger than another.
  5. Review the full rationale.Write down the principle you missed; try a different reviewed scenario later.

Keep learning

Choose the next step.

More SJT learning is on the way.

Reviewed scenario collections, topic resources and games will appear here only after their questions and explanations are approved. The Clinical revision hub is available separately.

Explore Clinical revision →
Scroll to Top